I have played Madden since the beginning. (yes I have) This version has improvements such as better franchise play, different commentators, teambuilder etc. The game, compared to recent past Madden games, is better than them but to me is a little underwhelming. The game is good but some of the "improvements" are past features that were put back in the game but as updated versions. This is a good thing I just hope these features stay and are improved upon in future versions. I don't dislike the game but to me it's not as good as others make it out to be nor as horrible as some suggest.
Graphics are still great and smooth. The game modes are better and will keep you busy.
Madden AI can be questionable, still no decent broadcast half time or post game and other issues. You can have a good experience with Madden but the game still hasn't struck a balance between simulation, immersion and fun.