In its latest attempt to resurrect the Man of Steel for a modern audience, Superman crashes harder than a Kryptonian asteroid—and not in a good way. What unfolds on screen isn’t just a cinematic misfire; it’s a philosophical affront, a glossy bastardization of both the Superman mythos and the very idea it was originally conceived to explore: the übermensch.
Let’s start with the obvious: Nietzsche’s concept of the übermensch—the “overman”—is not about a flying man in spandex saving cats from trees or delivering limp monologues about hope to a city he conveniently allowed to fall into disrepair. The übermensch is a radical ideal: one who transcends societal norms, carves their own morality, and acts as a creative force toward human evolution. He is not a savior from above, but an exemplar who rises from the human condition.
This film, instead, gives us a protagonist who is emotionally neutered, painfully earnest, and soaked in nostalgia for a morality that is both infantilizing and out of touch. The Superman here is not a visionary but a Boy Scout in a cape—moralizing without consequence, suffering without complexity. He’s less Nietzsche’s übermensch and more a boot-licking paragon of neoliberal civility. One might expect a god among men; instead, we get a glorified life coach who spouts platitudes like “You are stronger than you think” while punching generic space fascists into the sun.
Worse yet, the film tries to inject “depth” by dragging Superman into tired identity crises and sanitized existential dilemmas that feel ripped from a TED Talk rather than from the pages of mythic struggle. He’s torn between his alien and human sides, but not in any way that challenges the audience to think. There’s no risk, no rebellion, no ascent—just therapy sessions masquerading as plot. Imagine Nietzsche’s Zarathustra weeping into a glass of oat milk because he doesn’t feel “seen” by Metropolis.
The real crime here is how the film strips the Superman character of his revolutionary potential. Superman—at his best—is a metaphor for the future of humanity, a symbol of what we might become if we broke our chains. In this film, however, he’s a glorified middle manager of cosmic balance, constantly asking permission to be great. The übermensch acts beyond good and evil; this Superman just wants a five-star Yelp review.
Director and writers, in their cowardice, have replaced the profound with the palatable. They’ve neutered the aspirational and served us the digestible. And in doing so, they’ve betrayed not just the spirit of Superman, but the very philosophical root from which he sprang.
If Nietzsche saw this film, he wouldn’t say “God is dead.” He’d say “Superman is dead, and Hollywood killed him.”
Save yourself the existential dread—reread Thus Spoke Zarathustra instead.