I have watched three times in a span of two days, SPOILERS BELOW :)
All jokes aside, I adored this movie. No jumpscares? So what! No bloody murder? Whatever. The characters were casted brilliantly, this is what Matthew Lillard needed to come back as a villain (technically is he still a slasher?). There were nods to other things outside of the FNAF universe which I enjoyed (Stu Macher's knife cleaning for example) and the movie itself wasn't an obnoxious money grab that I genuinely believe can become a successful film series. My only minor issue was the "human plot" of Abby's custody battle, I'm not sure what purpose it served but alright. Garrett's disappearance and Abby's tendencies to wander off were interesting factors that added to Mike's stress of his security job.