Id give it an 8 on 10 tbh
Minus 2 because it was quite arrogant of pacchu to say "i lied because i love you" and quite naive of hamsadhwani to accept it and miss him. And also the "no" scene was exaggerated. No friend of 2 days can advise you what to do.
Apart from that, i liked how the kept the action scenes good. You dont automatically do action because you're a South indian man.
I liked the building of pacchu and hamsas relationship. I like how blunt pacchu was when he said "hes dead. You should start living for yourself". I liked how small characters played small roles in smaller stories, reminds everyone is a main character in their own life. I liked That chaddi scene. I liked when he said, "when the girl you love rejects you, you grow for the better". I loved how small the roles of the kid, the pennu kaanal pennu, the shopkeeper, the honking car was. I loved how the name of the movie fits in the movie. How he felt like he got hold of a magic lamp and didn't want to run out of that magic and hence lied.
I liked how he says his starsign along with his age when she asks.
That scene was my fav. The entire sequence.
Three sight of pacchu checking out her videos this creepy laga, pov hamsadhwani, but it was necessary yaar. Everything about the movie feels necessary. I wouldn't do without any. I loveddfffdddd it.
Its in my 2nd most fav films list.