Anyone who gave this show a rating before the ending of season 1, in my opinion, has no applicable voice. (Also, I am pointing more toward the people who are drowning in their negativity) I waited to give my review until I actually finished the show. The 5 stars really go to my pal Durin and Elrond. Their relationship was so pure and beautiful. I also wouldn’t down play the actress who played the very beautiful Galadriel. Oh and the Queen of Numenor, which I believed they captured an essence of elegance and strength. What I really appreciated about this show, was that they really tried to capture the magical feeling The Lord of The Rings trilogy gave. There were moments of poetry, serene music, epic fights and cgi, and excellent camera work. I laughed, I cried, and I shouted. And that is all I could ask for on a Friday night. :)