Griffin Stambaugh

I loved the first installment. This sequel is missing something. Maybe the map is just too large and empty, or maybe I don't like the combination system. But either way, 3.5/5.

Don't have internet issues with any other games but this one. And unlike other games, it is literally unplayable without internet connection. I own a game that I can't even play.

This game feels like playing a mafia movie based on Grand Theft Auto on a PS2 with a side of soft-core port. I think secretly everyone who liked this game just enjoyed Keanu Reeves and pixilated boobies, cause the story is painful to play through.

This game is great. Hands down a game you'll enjoy. The characters, game play, landscape, especially the story, are what make this game so enjoyable. What made it 4 stars for me were the quirks, like someone dying naturally and you get charged for murder, or your horse vanishing, or you trying to say hello and then get shot at and you shoot back and lose karma. These quirks don't take at all from the story, but dissuades you from exploring the mostly empty world of red dead.

Meh. So everything about game play and open world is right. I am with the critics though, the characters are painfully hard to care about.

Not very much has been added to the battle style. Story is a good bit better than previous titles. Graphics are a bit of a bomb. But I had a lot of fun playing this game.