I'm honestly convinced me and the critics watched completely different films. This film is literally AMAZING, and there aren't many films I can say that about.
The animatronics look like real animatronics and not just guys in costumes or suits. The relationship between Mike and Abby feels so real that you're almost convinced they're really siblings. And the bonding scenes between them and the animatronics...
Not only that, but the finale is really fun. All of them trapped in the pizzeria, and then the final killer just shows up to slaughter them all.
Please, watch this movie!