I think we need to stop comparing it to the original. I am a huge fan of the original. I have the book of shadows in my house for god sakes. This Charmed is fresh, new and has a different vibe.
Now with the introduction of the new sister in season 4, this is going to finally get this show back on track and continue on from season 1. I feel they lost direction in season 2/3. Yes many factors were involved like "covid" but they lost the magic aspect when they lost their powers.
Now it feels like a breath of fresh air for whats to come. More magic, more demons and more mystery. I give this 5/5 and season 4 promo 5/5.