Malcolm Stuart

Another Miscast Winslet - too old, (at least 10 years older than Miller was in 1945) too overweight, too blonde; spoiled what could have been a better film although there was not really much of interest to it - no usp to the film and nothing we haven’t seen before, done 100 times better. Screenplay was flat and no depth to the characters. Marion Cotillard was more impressive in her one main scene than Winslet in the whole film. Pretty boring most of the time.