I have mixed feelings about this documentary. First, the positives. I loved the rugged landscape of this isolated part of Ireland's southwest coast and the weather-beaten look of the cottages, old houses and farms of the area. I could see myself living there.
Now, the negatives. First of all, there was no need to drag this out over three episodes. Good editing and the rigorous guiding hand of a good director could easily have halved the running time to 75 minutes, max. Secondly, it was clear this was made with an agenda in mind. It would have been far more relevant to a viewer unfamiliar with this case to have seen more attention paid to the incompetency of the local Gardai in, among other things, not preserving the crime scene and losing critical pieces of evidence. For God's sake, how do you lose a large section of blood-stained iron fence?
At the end of the day, did I come away thinking that Ian Bailey could very well have been the killer? Yes. However, that said, only because of the incompetency of the local Gardai, I can understand why the DPP decided that, based on the Irish legal system where guilt must be proven beyond a reasonable doubt, a conviction would be unlikely.