Disappointing and Shallow - A Missed Opportunity for a Great Wizarding World Game
I was excited for Hogwarts Legacy, hoping it would deliver an immersive and engaging RPG experience. Unfortunately, it falls short in so many areas, especially when it comes to its story, characters, and lack of player agency.
First and foremost, the story feels underdeveloped and lacking in substance. What you get is a promising plot that ultimately leaves you unsatisfied. The central mystery of your character’s connection to the magical events around you never feels impactful, and by the end, you’re left with more questions than answers. The game's narrative feels like it was rushed or never fully fleshed out—nothing about it is particularly memorable.
The side characters are just as disappointing. They’re flat, uninspired, and never manage to evoke any real emotion or connection. While you’re given the opportunity to interact with them, they never feel like real people with depth or backstory, making it hard to care about their struggles or quests. You end up going through the motions just to get through the game.
Another major issue is the lack of meaningful choice in how you shape your character’s journey. You may be in the magical world, but you have very little influence over your own fate. Despite the game's open-world design, you’re ultimately stuck following a set path, with little room to make decisions that feel impactful. You can’t forge your own destiny in a world that should be built on freedom and possibilities.
Perhaps the biggest flaw, though, is the fact that you never really understand who your character is or how they fit into the larger narrative. No clear explanation of your background or your connection to the bigger story, you are just playing with an empty vessel. At no point do you feel like you’re truly discovering or growing with your character, you’re just going through the motions of a storyline that’s been done better elsewhere.
Overall, Hogwarts Legacy is a missed opportunity. It could’ve been a truly groundbreaking RPG set in one of the most beloved universes, but instead, it offers a shallow, uninspired experience that leaves you feeling disconnected from both the story and the world around you. If you’re looking for depth, meaningful choice, and engaging characters, look elsewhere.