I have read all of Mr.Frank Herbert's Dune books and most of His Son's. So as a fan who realizes I am not going to be watching 20hr movie I give 2 thumbs up. This doesn't imply it's perfect but more that the important points were hit. Now it isa must to see this in the theater and particularly IMax. The audio is intense and the Worms are great. If small screen then just scary earth worms. I just want part 2 now.