I watched this because a lot of people said it's good and praised it highly.
I'd agree that it is good, it had a lot of touching and funny moments. I'd highly praise the actors and their acting were amazing. It got me hooked by the first two episodes, especially during his childhood, that was so well made. The feelings it brought out and the hardship he had to face. Then making a choice of chasing his dream or protecting his family.
The time travelling aspect wasn't bothering me at first, but then.
Through episode 3 till 8 it keeps revolving around the same issue, performing as a band, they'd make an agreement, and then 15 mins later in the episode they broke it, and they used this plot over and over through this episode :)
(About Se Kyung)
Se Kyung threw me off even harder. Is it a plot hole or did I miss something? During the entire episode when Eun Gyeol keeps calling her ahjumma and we see glimpse of her backstory, her parents and how she's adopted. She didn't acknowledge him as much but we know it bothered her. About who his real father is, and her real father who keeps lingering around her.
.
And then we're introduced to another Se Kyung (the daughter who's pretending to be her mom, I forgot her name) and how did she randomly knows Eun Gyeol, "oh my mom's crush" when we know she doesn't even know him? This coupled with the fact, so whose's backstory did we even see previously? that made her so rebellious? Is it only because her mom is a drunk and keeps telling her about her crush?
.
Then, what does her, pretending to be the mom will even accomplish? She's not the og mom, whatever the love connection she makes, wouldn't effect the mom's marriage. Her motives feels very lacking? x'D
Next point, when Eun Gyeol knows about how his mother had actually lived, being mistreated by her family and abused. He abandoned all his past resolves to save the dad (that we have been basically cemented on for all 9 episodes)...? At this point I actually liked that they turned the plot around to be centered around the mom. AND THEN, 15 minutes later it's back to the band, festival, se kyung, and I don't know anymore. I thought he wanted to help the mom.
Makes me confused to root for him or not, because he keeps changing his mind at every second. And can we please just get over the festival, it's happening in one month but it felt like forever and they're never practicing and just keeps flip flopping on the same thing over and over :)
(I wrote this while currently on episode 10) I'm frustrated.
BUT I WILL CONTINUE WATCHING! Then maybe I will rewrite this review again. But I really love Chung Ah, her eyes speaks so much emotion!