This was by far my all-time favorite show. Yeah recasting witness numero dos wasn't the best move and neither was putting it on Friday night. The third and fourth seasons were good, but it didn't live up to the first two seasons, which were just amazing. I never once missed a single episode. However, bringing ol' Headless back for season four was definitely a good move and literally one of the only things that kept me watching. I never got tired of Ichabod's quips and wry comments. He was hands down one of the best characters in the show and while I love the short story that inspired it all, it was a good twist on Ichabod.