edward berns

Another excellent robert redford film both acted and directed. The romantic side is dealt with superbly

Very original. Simple story but fascinating as most simple stories are. And lovely black and white photography

Not well written or acted. Too long and the murder is half way into the film. The film is confused not knowing what direction to go in. Too many starring roles means that nobody stands out. Jennifer Saunders' role as a wealthy anti capitalist lefty is just silly and then she turns out to be gay! I don't see the point in the remake if it doesn't improve on the first film. And since when we electric guitars used in the 1930's

For a film costing $200 million you'd expect a decent script, decent acting and directing. It's unbelievably bad and how the studio allowed it to happen is incredible

Absolutely over the top. Where are all the script writers in film