David K

Terrible in every way. Disney's pandering to the perceived masses has hit a new low - they care more about their social credit score than they do about making good entertainment. George Lucas sold his soul to the devil.

If you love progressive identity hysteria, gender and race obsession, etc., you will LOVE this. If you love history, facts, etc., you will NOT love this.

The premise that an alien species would invade a planet that was literally covered in a substance that is poisonous to them is so unbelievable that I can't look past it. For one thing, there's no way a species with the technology to get here wouldn't know beforehand that not only is there water everywhere but the creatures on it are all mostly made of it. So if they decided to attack anyway, they would never actually land individuals but instead bombard us from orbit - or if they insisted on landing at least wear waterproof suits. I mean seriously, it's so utterly unfathomable that I can't take the film seriously. And aside from all that, you're telling me that God's strategy for divine intervention was to cut his wife in half so she could deliver a vague message for her husband's brother to beat an alien with a baseball bat?

This is easily Johnny Depp's worst performance of his life. As for the movie itself - it is painfully bad. They changed or removed everything that made the original great, and everything new they added was so cheap and boring. And seriously, whoever designed this new version of the Oompa Loompas deserves to be blacklisted from the movie business for life.

Show is great. Love baby Yoda. And Gina Carano looks unbelievably HOT with the weight she put on for this role.

Not sure why the critics hate it so much

Hands down the greatest fantasy film of all time. The sets are sublime works of art. The music and ambient sound effects are perfect. The acting is all spot on perfect. And the costumes and makeup - words don't do them justice. I can't explain what this movie does for me emotionally. All I can say is that it evokes a deeper emotional response in me than any other movie ever has. Ridley Scott is a genius.

This movie is BRILLIANT. Like, in the top 25 movies of all time brilliant. If Joaquin Phoenix doesn't win an Oscar for this, I will have officially lost all faith in the system.

Great visuals, and the first 3/4 are super realistic. However, at some point this movie takes a nose dive. It goes from realistic, high budget space movie to over-the-top, low budget, father son redemption movie. I mean, why focus so much on realistic details and special effects if you're going to have the main character tear off a piece of a spaceship and use it as a shield to float through a ring system and miraculously land on your ship? Whoever wrote this movie deserves to burn in hell, and Tommy Lee Jones should be ashamed of himself for this "performance".