Not sure why the reviews for this show are so critical. I actually liked this series and this is coming from someone who loves drama, mystery, coming of age, romance, and thriller movies/shows. Certainly, not all in one show but I think City on Fire was a good drama series, and, considerably, a good thriller.
I did not read the book by Garth Risk Hallberg so I cannot compare it to the actual book. But I can compare it to other drama/ murder mystery series. City on Fire is similar to Gossip Girl or other New York drama series that include love affairs, drug addiction, and corporate scandals. I love a good drama and the City on Fire tv series is an excellent drama that keeps the audience entertained with a good thriller. This show includes all of the elements that a good drama would have such as a love affair, drug addiction, family drama, troubled children, corruption, socioeconomic issues, poverty, corporate scandals, etc. So if you love a good drama I definitely recommend this show.
I think the actors in this show did pretty well. Some of the actors for the minor characters certainly could have done a better job but the main characters were exceptional in my opinion. The actors for the main characters, Charlie (Wyatt Oleff) and Sam (Chase Sui Wonders) played their roles perfectly. Wonders did an amazing job playing her character with so much beauty and charisma. And we can’t forget Jemima Kirke (Regan) and Nico Tortorella (William) who did an excellent job in their roles. You really can’t complain too much about the acting or the characters because, overall, it was great.
The only reason why I didn’t give it 5 stars is because the show could have done a better job in portraying a more realistic aspect of the dramas surrounding each character and plot twists. I agree with some of the reviews that it’s a bit of a cliche especially with all the terrorism and extreme radicals who are secretly formulating a plan to bomb the city with the help of New York elitists. It’s certainly a cliche that a college freshman is having an affair with a married man who happens to be wealthy and a rapist. Honestly, all of it is a cliche and some of the best shows and movies are built on cliches. So I don’t think this show is any different.
I believe the reason why so many people are critical about this show and calling it “an absolute mess” is probably because they are comparing it too much to the book. Also, there might be a strong dislike for teen dramas because this show was like any other teen drama with some mystery and thriller. Honestly, if you liked the original Gossip Girl (2007) series, then you will like this show. City on Fire may not have lived up to its potential when compared to the book but coming from someone who just enjoys a good drama series, I could honestly say I really like this show and I wish there would be a second season but, unfortunately, this series did not make the cut for a second season. I’m honestly disappointed with some of the reviews because they’re a little harsh. This show really isn’t that bad. And if people would just allow themselves to watch a tv series without comparing it to the book and having such high expectations then you may actually enjoy a good series, like City on Fire.