Paul Tofflemire

I’m seeing so many 5 star reviews. People that have watched this series must be easily impressed, or just having Yellowstone hangover. The girl playing Elsa Dutton was terrible. I don’t know who gave her lessons on using a southern accent…it was annoying. Her teeth were perfect and white. Her first boyfriend was killed in a gunfight and within a matter of a few days, she was back in the sack with a Comanche warrior. They try to mask her promiscuity and disrespect as a strength and independence. It was totally unbelievable. Sam Elliot, Tim McGraw and Faith Hill did stellar jobs of acting and the scenery was breath taking. That is the only thing that saved this series. I haven’t seen 1923 yet but I hear it is much better than this train wreck. You’ll have to watch this series if you are a Yellowstone fan, but just prepare yourself for many cringe moments and hard to believe scenarios.

The show started out pretty good all the way through the 1st season. The scenery was beautiful and the characters had good chemistry. Then it got into lies, mistrust, "don't tell so and so"...and that person would tell so and so. Then some person would get mad because they didn't tell so and so...because that person made a promise not to tell so and so. I was turned off halfway season 3. Just wanted to finish it and be done with it.