While James' review harshly criticizes the casting and writing of this new sci-fi series, I found it to be a refreshingly original and thought-provoking show. The diverse cast of young, attractive scientists admittedly doesn't fit the stereotypical mold, but that's precisely what makes it so intriguing.
Too often, scientists and academics are portrayed as awkward and unattractive in popular media. This series bucks that trend and imagines a world where intelligence and passion for science can coexist with conventional beauty and charisma. While the dialogue may occasionally feel a bit clunky, the characters still come across as brilliant yet flawed human beings. Their struggles to merge their personal lives with their professional callings as scientists ring true.
The review also faults the show for trying to push a "diversity and inclusion agenda." However, I saw the diverse cast not as forced representation, but as a realistic depiction of the countless underrepresented groups making vital contributions to STEM fields. If the goal is to inspire more young people from all backgrounds to pursue science, depicting diverse scientists as intelligent and attractive seems like an effective approach.
Yes, there are moments of tonal whiplash, swinging from serious drama to broad comedy. But I saw that as an ambitious artistic choice to capture the full emotional spectrum that scientists undoubtedly experience, rather than a flaw. The scenes set in Mao's China provide a compelling historical counterpoint to the modern-day storylines.
While not every joke or line of dialogue lands perfectly, the series possesses a audacious creative energy that is frankly lacking in most sterile, risk-averse sci-fi programming today. It's a flawed but impassioned love letter to science itself - the sense of wonder, the ethical dilemmas, and the very human characters devoting their lives to furthering knowledge.
To dismiss this series as only for those with low IQs is itself a remarkably unintelligent take. Open-minded viewers willing to go along for the ride will find an uneven but bracingly original sci-fi vision worth celebrating. The flaws are a small price to pay for such an admirably daring artistic swing.