Don't go by single star reviews posted by obvious beta males and females, they would use various lingos to tag this movie but before taking their word or mine, watch it for yourself and see if you don't feel something.
It doesn't matter if you are a man or woman, this version and the telugu one are masterpieces, stir so much within you with raw emotions and portray how actually people react in their daily day to day lives, and yes since it's a movie their are extremities but this is very much close to reality than what's shown in DDLJ or K3G crap genre of movies fed to us.