The graphics are fantastic. Incredible, scenic locations that are a clear upgrade over the prequel.
The gameplay is also great, though the old loop of "stealth and loot" does get stale after a while.
Here's the problem: the story. The story is an absolute trainwreck. So many problems with it; from horrible character expositions, bizarre and logic-defying time skips, a very barebones motive that drives the main character(s), etc.
TLOU1 was a masterpiece. This was, comprehensively, a very mundane and average game. If you've watched GoT S8 - this game is very similar in the reward and satisfaction you'll derive from it. (Hint: not very much).