Overall 7/10 . It’s a good game and you get the 3D Zelda experience. However, there are a couple of things which make the game annoying. First, the motion controls were a cool concept but glitch quite a lot. When you get punished for not striking the right way it can become frustrating (ghirahim, pirate skeletons, etc.).
Secondly, the quest lines were good but there is a certain miniboss you have fight 3 times the exact same way, which feels overdone. The four-spirit realm “minigames” are also annoying and felt like a nuisance. The dungeons were creative but i felt the entire overworld felt like a dungeon. Even getting to the actual dungeons felt like a dungeon rahter than open world exploration.
Lastly, the characters I felt lack the charm that they have in other Zelda games. There is only one town (skyloft) and it feels tiny at times. Most of the characters you meet and interact with are forgettable.