This movie got a 3 star because I'm not sure where to place it.
If it was purely a campy B movie type: I would've given it a 5. Delightful guilty pleasure movie for laughs, gore, and cheap thrills.
If it was meant to be a serious follow-up to original Pet Sematary, it failed miserably and would've given it a 1. Not even the dog death scene got me riled up...