I would to start off by pointing out that anyone calling this a JL ripoff missed the entire concept of this show. Like the boys, this is a mix of super hero parady and a "what if super heros were real" scenario that places emphasis on super heros can have the same human flaws as the rest of humanity.
Now onto my personal take on this show: I found the dynamics of the entire show to be well thought out orchestrated to reflect each character as well as the overall plot. At no moment did I find myself bored during the entire first season of this show as each scenario maintained relevance to the overall plot line without getting drawn too long out to the point of annoyance which I often find in other shows. The story line and how it progressed kept me engaged as an audience member. As far as the character dynamics itself, I really enjoyed the development of the characters and while like any show of it's genre that exaggerates many aspects of events and character flaws, the general concept of how flawed a super hero likely would be if real was quite realist. This is most certainly more captivating than any borderline teeny-bopper BS you would find on CW's DC series.
The special effects (the animated portrayals of many scenes and characters) at first seemed a little off putting, but actually added into the entertainment with some dark comedy factor that I pleasantly enjoyed. Furthermore, I really did enjoy much of the 80s/90s style themes of the animated scenes that once again keep me engaged and fit well into the overall theme of the show and series of events.
Personally, I find this show to be on par with the likes of Amazon's The Boys and hope I can look forward to another season. Sadely, I have to remain spectacle because I feel the dynamics and overal concept of this show to go over many people's heads. I feel while this show gives off a strong 80s/90s vibe at times, it may actually be a bit ahead of the times in some ways.