The fact that this took me 2 years to finish tells you all you need to know.
Loved the world and the AI, poker was fun, story was aight (tho extremely overrated) and the music was neat too.
Did not enjoy the endless shooting galleries (gunplay also feels outdated and clunky), restrictive and repetitive missions, utterly terrible player/horse movement (spamming the A button to move faster is simply obnoxious), over-animated and tedious game mechanics that should be way simpler (i.e crafting split-point rounds) and overall the game was just way too long with far too much filler which resulted in me abandoning the game multiple times in favour of more fun and engaging games that don’t waste my time literally cleaning up poo (yes, there is an actual mission in the game where you have to shovel cowpats).
And the Online is so fundamentally BROKEN that it’s not even worth talking about.