An Honest Review/Discussion
Note: SPOILERS AHEAD
As a TLOU fan from the beginning and player of both games including DLC, I really enjoyed this narrative, but this is also more of a character study piece (see “No Country For Old Men”) so I understand why some people feel slighted. I’m seeing a lot of people arguing that Abby was an unwelcome addition, but I really don’t understand why. I feel that she really added a lot of power, widening the scope and making us realize that both Ellie and Abby are both in the moral gray; they are the “heroes” and “villains” of each other’s stories, but no one is really “right”. I even found myself resistant to Abby at first, but her bonding with Lev made it impossible for me to not pine for her. Abby clearly has a “Tess” moment, realizing that she couldn’t help but do something for these kids that don’t know any better and hated on all sides; a chance at redemption for her actions but also simply a peek into how she’s not the heartless person she’s shown as during Joel’s death. Joel’s end resulted from his own actions + her father, the man who could create the cure, was killed for a selfish reason. Because of this, I found myself caring for Abby and her loved ones even when I didn’t want to, so I’ll never understand the problems with her on that front. I found myself in a crazy conflict with myself, not knowing who i was rooting for because I loved both Ellie and Abby and empathized with both of them. It’s an incredibly risky gamble, but I can’t help but give ND props. I will say the time jumps were running a little rampant near the middle and latter half, making things a little confusing to piece together sometimes. The story also felt stretched occasionally, with some gameplay taking up a bit longer than I felt was necessary encounter-wise. Also, the Seraphites felt a little underdeveloped, as I never really got a good sense of who they we’re simply as people; some more noticeable moments of empathy would have done them a lot more good. Nevertheless, I did understand that they were a religious believers run amok and immediately made the IRL parallels. Besides these few qualms, I truly enjoyed this game and the story it told.
8.5/10