If you have ever had a family member struggling with depression, this movie offers an excellent view into the process of recovery, not only for the person with the depression monster on their shoulder, but for whatever family members (in this case the wife) are trying to help and are in anguish themselves. Why any critic would find disfavor with this movie is puzzling. The performances are excellent, as is the script, direction, editing and the interwoven story line of the Starling bird's impact within the human drama. There is humor to be found as well. I say, good job. Perfect film to view at home on Netflix.