I can understand comments from people who give 5 star rating, which start sentences like " I was a fan since first movie LOTR came out", Im not speaking to those people becouse movie is their only reference . And I can agree Peter Jackson done a good job with LOTR, Hobit, ok he struggled but managed to again capture what book was all about. By saying so, if you are a person, who actually read a books J. R. R. Tolkien Hobit, LOTR, Silmarilion, and then his sons Christophers, Children of Hurin, Beren and Luthien and Unfinished tails you will find this disappointing. All this things which are captured by the books about Elves, their grace, wisdom, courage, presence, magnificent i cannot found here, same things with other characters which when I was reading a book found them amazing so complete, and after all persons who act in dificcult situations as heros with a flows but again their capture me as amazing caracthers. If I conclude what I saw, ok with that kind of money its expected that visuals are amazing, but all others, they could just simplify by naming this: Elfs, Dwarfs Humans fighting Some bad Guys which maybe have dragons as well. This woke show have nothing to do with Tolkien...