When I read the synopsis of An Unexpected Christmas, it was clearly a trope-filled, predictable holiday movie, complete with an estranged couple who fake still being together for the sake of his family having the happiest Christmas possible, it being the first Christmas without grandpa, the Christmas crazy patriarch. This, and some plot points that demand you think, โOh, what the heck, Iโll believe these crazy coincidences because the two leads are just so damn cuteโ, and suspend any cynical doubts.
And the two leads are what brings this tightly written, funny, full of nuts, Christmas pudding to a boil, and keeps it there. The skilled duo of Tyler Hynes and Bethany Joy Lenz as Jamie and Emily, manage to capture the awkwardness and soulfulness of exes, who have split, but still have the big feels for each other. Seeing and liking their work on other projects was what made me decide to take a look at An Unexpected Christmas, and Iโm very glad I did.
Although Iโm really late to the Hallmark Christmas Party, scoffing for years, then getting sucked into them a couple of years ago, I have no regrets. My inner sentimental fool has been let loose, and itโs fun. It doesnโt mean that I all of sudden stopped seeing the clichรฉs, or feel the sometimes glacial pace of the lesser Hallmark offerings, which I can enjoy as much as the next person, but itโs so wonderful to see a holiday film where you canโt see any of the machinery, the motivations are believable, the characters, even the secondary and third ones are all real, and engaging, even the waiter who almost blows the coupleโs cover has several lovely moments.
The film also has a divorced gay character, the lesbian sister and confidante of Jamie, is real, funny, and smart, very positively adding to the world the film successfully creates.
I had the best time watching An Unexpected Christmas, and I know you will to.