You know for me the given degratory reveiws from all these highly reputed critics who have mastered in the kind of stuff means absolutely nothing.. If you want an honest reply from a yet another person sitting in the audience like all of you ..... then I would say it's heart melting, the best movie I have ever watched; makes you weep and smile like a crazy person.... it's simply the best I would strongly suggest you all to definatly gives it a try..... it so carefully portraits the deep and eternal bonding between a father and his daughter which is just so pure and overwhelming...