My two daughters 26yrs and 9 yr old and myself thought it was good! It had lots of humor, excitement, flare, swag and fun. We all enjoyed it the best Alladdin ever! I think the critics who rated it down are just haters. I thought it was awesome. I think Will Smith did the movie justice. Change is good especially for this new time in life. We saw it 3D and it was great! My youngest who's a picky critic loved it. She said it was better than the original. Not taking anything away from Robin but it had swag and lots of great humor and personality. Please go and see the movie.