This is a story that grips your attention from the first sentence. As a piece of fictional writing, it is amazing. You become emerged into the story, feeling empathy for the characters and visualizing the sights and sounds of the journey.
I understand where the negativity comes from - why aren’t more Latin-x authors represented, why was this story told by a white woman, and so on. These concerns about an industry are warranted, but concerns about the fictional novel itself are unwarranted.
I see fictional movies to escape the world and experience something different. Likewise I read fiction to escape into another person’s story. Let’s remember that it is a piece of realistic fiction, and authors should never be shoved into a box and told what they can or cannot write about, and readers should not be told what not to read. Are slavery fiction novels written by slaves? Holocaust novels by Jewish authors? War novels by direct survivors? It’s ridiculous to judge a book by what an author looks like or where they live.
Read a book and decide if you like it or not, and don’t judge a book “based on its cover”. I read this book and it is amazing, immersive, and helps put the plight of Hispanic immigrants into the minds of white America. I honestly didn’t want it to end. I wanted to know what happens to the characters 5-10 years down the road. And when I see an immigrant now, I will be more compelled to see the person and not just another immigrant.