I hated this game... For about 15 hours. This review is for those people who haven't played it yet because they didn't get into, late to the party, or have replayed the first section too many times etc.
An honest review. The introduction (chapter 1) is painfully slow and largely unenjoyable. Yes, the animations are drawn out. Yes, the travelling can actually become tedious even tho it's pretty. Yes, it can be janky as hell. Yes, the cores and rings of your health, dead, eye, stamina, horse stamina, horse health, cleanliness etc is just convuluted.
But it's all worth it.
I suggest getting the best horse in the game as soon as you can. And if you are on PC to mod this game, don't fidde with it too much, trainers like Rampage allow you to warp your horse to you, teleport you to way points seamlessly, and increase your horse stats. The truth is, you'll want to travel everywhere, just not multiple times, nor will you want to do it on a slow as hell horse and this trainer carves off about 10 hours of stupid backtracking and tedium out of the main story alone. So to me, it was a positive game changer.
You'll still have to walk like a snail through camp and tolerate the terrible wagons you need to drive all the time. But warping to the other side of the camp helped my sanity so often.
I really wasn't interested in the hunting aspect of the game. I did this in RDR1 and every other open world game and here its better than ever but a time sink I didn't want to invest in again, a trainer can really help by allowing you to speed up this process immensely.
This game is worth it, but if you've got open-world burn out you'll need some assistance because this game moves at its own pace and that is pace is sloooooow. It's really slow. The meat of the game is experiencing its world and how your little actions react in this world. The story is great but unfolds at a snails pace until it's in full gear.
I'm 4 years late to playing this but it was finally worth it. It's technically brilliant. It's not my favourite game. But it deserves the praise even through the frustration.