THE SEA HAWK, a Swashbuckling adventure, represented what was already a well-worn genre by the time the film arrived on theater screens, in 1940. It's also an Erroll Flynn vehicle, using a narrative template still beloved and likely expected by his fans. Flynn is Geoffrey Thorpe, a bad boy with a heart of gold, righting wrongs with his sword and rakish smile. In these films, Flynn's romantic lead was always a proper lady who can't resist a benevolent rogue. Audiences were also primed to expect supporting players like Alan Hale and Claude Rains to show up. And they did, having appeared with Flynn in THE PRINCE AND THE PAUPER, as well as ADVENTURES OF ROBIN HOOD. Hale (whose son would later portray the Skipper on Gilligan's Island) would do his oafish comic relief shtick as the sidekick while Rains as the heavy, usually sported an eccentric period hairstyle. His characters always exuded sleaziness with a veneer of dismissive snobbery. THE SEA HAWK didn't disappoint audiences or the studio, making it one of 1940's box office successes.
I became aware of the film back in the 1960s when my parents purchased the rousing Erich Korngold soundtrack album. Korngold is a composer known to many John Williams fans since his score for STAR WARS is obviously influenced by the Korngold sound, jaunty arrangements full of triumphant brass and strings.
The best that can be said about the restored version of THE SEA HAWK is that it showcases the stunning black & white cinematography of Sol Polito. The restoration really makes you appreciate the skill of the native Sicilian who shot an exhaustive but impressive list of Warner Bros' films, including Flynn's ADVENTURES OF ROBIN HOOD, a prime example of gorgeous Technicolor work.
Personally, we found the film less than rousing and talkier than most action films directed by Michael Curtiz, a man responsible for a number of amazing classics including CASABLANCA. The problem may have been an unwieldy script by Howard Koch and Seton Miller, though among the best in the business, they may have been uncomfortable around period adventures set on the high seas. It seemed a very hit and miss affair, as if cobbled together by too many hands. Possibly I was distracted by the film's lengthy galley slave sequence. I half expected Flynn's character to escape from ship and make his way to Rome as a gladiator. Of course, I'm kidding but if it were re-made today, someone would pitch the idea that the protagonist slips into time warp....