I will attempt to do this without too much bias from my 5-year-old self who fell in love with the 1992 Disney classic, "Aladdin." I took my girls to see the live-action version today and it did not fail to deliver. Without any spoilers, here is what had me leaving the theater feeling like a kid with a dumb smile on my face. Jasmine was physically gorgeous and vocally spectacular. I did not know who Naomi Scott was going into this, but she certainly has my vote for future films. The way she belted "A Whole New World" and crushed her two new solos restored my faith in modern vocalization. She didn't necessarily sound like every pop-star born out of whatever reality t.v contest happened to be poisoning the nation at the time. Her voice seemed more pure, unique, and fresh. And whether or not you're into "extreme feminism" or "women empowerment" I would say, as a father of two women-in-training, most can agree that she was a breath of fresh air from your typical Disney princess without being over the top or anti-man.
While Jafar's mannerisms were certainly maniacal and it was clear that he was obsessed with taking the throne, I had a difficult time with his voice. Jonathan Freeman (1992 Jafar) sounded like and delivered his lines in a way you would expect a classic villain. In my opinion, the new voice of Jafar left something to be desired. That said, the character overall was decently played and got the job done.
Our main protagonist had the look and moves, but again, it was a voice thing for me. Perhaps this is in part to the fact that I had Steve from "Full House" and the singing talents of Brad Kane stuck in my mind. I understand you are trying to be different than your predecessor, but there were some sung lines that seemed short and cut-off; possibly even hesitant. Like Jafar, Aladdin was mostly positives and certainly held my attention.
On to sets, scenery, and costumes. What can I say? They were absolutely visually stunning! The colors were crisp and vibrant and the set designs gorgeous. The way everything flowed together with such ease made you feel as though you were in Agrabah. I imagine the 3-D would have been incredible, as you can clearly see how certain scenes were made specifically for it.
Well, I suppose that's it. I don't believe I am missing anyone important... JUST KIDDING! I had to save the best for last. Let's just agree right now that the late, beloved Robin Williams certainly MADE the Genie, and increased the overall quality of the original classic by about 200%. Nobody could ever reprise his role and do it justice. Anyone taking on this blue powerhouse would absolutely have to do their own thing, and Will Smith did NOT disappoint. With great respect for Mr. Williams, Mr. Smith originally declined the role, but I could not be happier that he reconsidered. Everyone knows "Big Willie" can drop a beat but the way he rocks the vocals in all of his singing numbers is enough to make the part his. Add that to his personal twist on the humor and he IS the complete Genie package.
All in all, I would give "Aladdin" an 8/10. It is a great watch for the whole family as children and adults alike will laugh, dance, and sing along to this modern Disney masterpiece.