I liked the idea behind the show and maybe with a few tweaks in the rules it could be a satisfying show to watch.
However, as it was played in season one, I felt like the game penalized players that did well and was not fair. The better a contestant did, the less likely they were to win in the end.
The ultimate winner definitely did not deserve to win as much as many of the other players. She basically just sat around all season and did almost nothing.