This breaks my heart to say. The original Last of Us is my all-time favorite game. -A true masterpiece, and a formative moment in my own history. This game, however, was a massive disappointment to me. A major issue that I had (spoilers ahead) was that Ellie knew what Joel did, and should have been able to understand why any number of people might want him dead. Afterall, he killed about 100 people who were looking for a cure. This revenge story made no sense to me at all. All of the light and hope of the first game is gone here, with an ending that left me feeling empty and betrayed, traumatized even.
I get that Joel had to die, I could have accepted that for this story, but why did Ellie, a thoughtful, worldy, and intelligent person respond to Joel's murder in a way that no sane human ever would? Why didn't she go looking for the Fireflies after discovering she could still offer the cure? Wouldn’t that have given her life meaning? -Because the only surgeon who could perform the procedure was dead? The idea that the entire knowledge of how to develop a vaccine has disappeared from the world isn't convincing to me at all.
Finally, I want to add that this game looked stunning. Visually this is the most beautiful game I have ever seen. Next gen even. The artists who worked on this game are hands down the best in the industry. I hope they were paid well for their excellent work. The setting was awe inspiring. The game mechanics and level design were also a satisfactory evolution of the first game. Animations seem eerily real. Unfortunately the game as a whole was an enormous disappointment that I wish I could simply forget.