I like the franchise, and have watched UK Australia New Zealand and Canada versions. The US one is by far the least interesting. Each season features a stable of reality show “stars” and therein lies the problem. They’re all vying for camera time and are well- eased in how to give the audience moments of drama or suspense- or at least this is what producers hope for. It ends up being a fashion show, with the ringleader being the host Allan Cummings. I used to like him but he comes off rather clownish, with each outfit tackier than the last, and he really tries to chew up the screen with his over the top Scottish brogue and dramatic movements.
The show ends up being tiresome and uninteresting. It’s much better when the contestants are ordinary citizens with many different careers, ages and so on. Watch the original UK version instead. Australia is apparently cancelled, and unsure if others are coming back. There have been many versions but not all have been successful.
My feeling is viewers will tire of the format unless producers can think of ways to shake up the game each season, and surprise us in different ways. Three seasons in, and it all seems a bit too familiar.