Click here for a video version of this review: youtu.be/CtfnvtxKyVY
Have you ever watched a movie that put a hand through your chest, grabbed your heart and threatened to rip it out? Well let me tell you about a movie called Apostasy. It’s a film that didn’t seem to get a wide release so has pretty much flown under the radar.
Here is the description:
"A faithful Jehovah's Witness is forced to shun her own sister because of a religious transgression. As the separation draws out, she starts to question the meaning of God's love."
The reason this movie hit home for me is that I used to be a Jehovah’s Witness, and of all the representations of Jehovah’s Witnesses I’ve seen on big and small screen, this is the most accurate look at what life is like behind the doors of a Kingdom Hall.
The reason for this accuracy is because the writer / director, Daniel Kokotajlo is himself a former Jehovah’s Witness. While it might not mean too much to the average viewer, this attention to detail is really important. Often when Jehovah's Witnesses are shown in TV and movies, the inaccuracies are used by the Witnesses to say "oh its all fake news and propaganda against us!" This movie however, nails what its like to be a Witness, and anyone being honest would have to say that apart from a few small things they very accurately recreate things very well.
They use all the right terms, they capture the inner monologue that goes on, the feeling of inadequacy about others that seem more spiritual than you, right down to even the cadence of public talks, and other little things like how when someone asks you a question you can't answer, you just open a Watchtower publication to provide the answer. They really show what a suppressed and stagnant life it can be - all the while you are telling everyone how happy you are and how it's the best life ever. If you have friends or family who are or were Jehovah's Witnesses and want to know what that life is like this will give you a very good insight.
From a technical aspect, I really liked how there is hardly any music in this. This means that there is a very subdued tone to everything, the actors have to act and the movie benefits very much from this. They also make great use of close ups meaning there is a real claustrophobic feeling to the film, and again, gives you an accurate feel of being closely watched and monitored and judged, as you are constantly as a Witness. It's all quite suffocating.
The end result is that it's a pretty devastating critique of Jehovah's Witnesses done through the eyes of three family members going through a crisis, and how their faith impacts their separate paths through it. The three leading ladies are absolutely brilliant and bring the required gravitas to their roles, and communicate so very well the struggle. It is a quiet, subdued, and deliberately slow paced movie, it is very much a "show, don't tell" approach to film making. It comes out as being accessible to everyone from current Jehovah's Witnesses, to ex Jehovah's Witnesses, to non Jehovah's Witnesses.
This movie is a downer, but in such a good and powerful way.