I gave it 3 stars, I liked the history of learning more about the Dutton family and I thought Sam Elliott was Isabel May had great performances, however I wasn't crazy about Tim Mcgraw and Faith Hill's perfomance, I would say that it was average and I was so confused at the end when Elsa died? So she went horseback riding in heaven with the Indian guy who was still living but had nothing to do with or didn't go riding with the first guy she fell in love with who was actually dead too?