On season 4 (spoiler free)
First off, the editing is terrible and it ruins the pacing. How many small scenes can they make from one? That seems to be their goal here. The laboratory scene in episode 4 was ruined by this NCIS style of editing. This is supposed to be prestige television, so why does it feel like something from CBS? That entire lab scene should’ve been ONE SCENE, maybe two. But instead it’s cut into five or six different scenes and it completely destroys the tension. They do the same for fight scenes; cutting away in the middle of a fight just to give us more info about something unrelated. This can work, but they don’t use it effectively. I’d much rather have half the show take place in one location with no cuts and have the tension ratchet up to 100, than have multiple cuts taking us back and forth across the environment with minimal to no tension. GoT, for all its faults, could do this well. So why can The Boys? Why can’t they break the shackles of their primetime cable tv roots and become something better?
And Frenchie. What happened to my boy Frenchie? What have you done to him? Where’s the quirky, clever, techie with a heart of gold from season 1? Who’s this depressed man-child who can’t focus on the job and pines over a love interest we’ve never seen before? No one cares about Colin. Their relationship is entirely unearned and cheap. You’re ruining Frenchie by stooping to this level.
Finally, this show used to be all about satirizing the real world - from all sides. But now they seem to focus only on making fun of the conservative right. Where’s the satire about the toxic left? Lord knows they’ve got plenty of ammunition from the real world to work with. Why is their humor becoming so directed and pointed? The best part of the humor with The Boys was that it didn’t take a side; it was above all that. But I don’t think the same could be said about the show today. They clearly have a side and aren’t afraid to show us.
These aspects haven’t ruined the show for me - yet - but this season is sapping most of the goodwill they’ve built up over time for me. If they don’t course correct soon I’m afraid The Boys will be over before their story concludes.
The best episode of the season was the very last episode - but for everything it does right it’s worst offense is that it highlights just how rudderless this season has been up to this point. I never knew what they were working towards, what the overarching plot was, and just because they showed us at the very end what it was building towards doesn’t mean they were justified in taking that route. There was no direction for this season, no goals or missions they were trying to accomplish. Just an end result the writers had to get to. Unfortunately I think this show needs to go back to being directed solely by one person - sorry I don’t recall his name, but the guy who directed the last episode. The show needs some authorship to get back on its feet. It’s time they stopped treating this like NCIS or Law and Order.