Close to five starts if she had one or two more songs that added depth to the EP. Overall the EP is a solid foundation work showing some similarity to her older work. I would say three songs of the EP are strong (not necessarily the singles btw) and they explore her connection to love. Remember her overall audience, and what her artistic style and thematics are. She explores a more interpersonal relationship with her hispanohablante listeners, because Spanish is a more personal connection when it comes to describing emotions. You can compare her to other artists who are not as big and say how its mediocre, but look at the overall. The audience, the thematics, the style; focusing on that you see a solid foundation for Selena Gomez's repertoire.