This book was really awesome but a little traumatic I loved Atlas from starting and when I saw almost all readers defending ryle I thought how really how can someone defend domestic violence?!!! I know ryle had a horrible past but what about lily? She also didn't had it easy right? Only they can understand lily who have seen such things in their life too and I also don't hate ryle he is 10 out of 10 if he didn't hurted lily I would have never shipped lily with Atlas but I do and I am proud of my decision!!!! BTW the book was really amazing ๐๐ปโค