Story 6/10: Its well ehh.. The pacing is not the best. You walk around a lot just gathering stuff which can take away from the feeling of being on a quest for revenge. The game also doesn't do a great job of capturing Ellie and Abby's lust to kill. I felt like they could have done a better job at really showing just how much they thirst for revenge. Again that is partly due to the pacing of the game. Playing as Abby you spend a good portion of time doing 'something' that doesn't even have to do with this games story (probably building up the plot for TLOU 3) but again! it really ruins the pace. For me playing as Abby was dull and uninteresting. The game never did a good job at making me care about Abby like TLOU 1 did with Ellie and Joel.
Combat 8/10: The combat is good and it is almost exactly like the first game except for a few new things like being able to go prone. Why I am only giving it an 8/10 is because I wish they had added more new things to make it fresh. The combat can get repetitive at times but then there's usually something good around the corner that will get your heart racing again.
Overall the game is good it is in no way a 10/10 like a lot of critics are giving it but it is also not a 3/10. For me is a solid 7/10.