Is it a good movie? Does it feel like Star wars? That is something people have to experience for themselves.
Truth is, we value Star Wars way too much. If you think about it, almost every movie of the saga was heavily criticised when it came out. They are not masterpieces. A new hope was iconic for its time, Yes! Empire strikes back is probably the last good Star wars film... Every other Star wars movie is an ok movie with some great moments... But we love them... We learn to love them... So why are the sequels any different?