I binged The Gilmore Girls just this spring and absolutely loved it! However, the "Year in the Life" was difficult to watch. At times, many times, I felt the actors were trying to get back into their character's mindset but just couldn't quite get there. Perhaps too many years since the series ended.....
The Stars Hollow Musical was a waste of ten to 15 minutes and I wonder why they had that in the script?
Kudos to Kelly Bishop, Liza Weil and Scott Patterson for bringing back their character's personalities perfectly.