I'm a big fan of 101 Dalmations, both the books and the films. The 90s films with Glenn Close are my favourite, and I've loved to HATE Cruella ever since. She's fabulously evil; a truly wicked villain. I was skeptical about the new adaptation for one reason: I want Cruella de Vil to remain a villain. Nothing about her is redeemable. There is nothing to redeem. She's an evil, rich fashion designer who kills animals to create fur clothing. That's it, and that's all there needs to be.
Spoilers ahead:
The new film makes her too much of an anti-hero. I was waiting for the moment where we would see Estella transform into Cruella with no hope of going back. She would truly become her real mother's daughter, and she would be deliciously, horribly evil. It doesn't have to be graphic. She still could have been somewhat "kid-friendly", like the Cruella we know already. An evil villain of a children's story. The new film could have shown us what led her to become the fashion designer and dog thief who wants to skin puppies for their fur. Instead, we got a "brilliant", plucky young woman who rose up against the fashion bourgeoisie. Someone who chose to spare a woman's dalmatian puppies and is a school friend of Anita Darling. School friends? Really? I have to groan. Cruella is now a woman who gifted Pongo and Perdita to Anita and Roger (the parent dogs of the original 101 Dalmation litter). The ending makes zero sense. Zero sense. Disney tried (emphasis on tried) to be too clever. Too clever, yet also far too literal as I hated that Cruella's natural hair was black and white. Really? I'd have preferred it if Estella was a redhead, and she donned a black and white wig while disguised as Cruella, and later purposely dyed her hair when Cruella fully took over (symbolising that Estella was truly gone). She chose to become Cruella, and she was now black and white, the duel colours of good and evil over red (a warning colour for danger, but a colour of love and passion).
The only hint the film gave us that Cruella was going to become truly bad...they had to tell us. An origin story should make sense, and it should link to the original source material. A film should SHOW us that Cruella is bad. It shouldn't have to TELL the audience at the last minute, assuring us that this Cruella will be evil one day, don't worry.
As a stand-alone film, I like it. Visually, it's stunning. The cast is great, and I forgive Emma's dodgy accent. The outfits are wonderful. The soundtrack is brilliant, and I hope it introduces a new generation to music by the likes of The Doors. There are some Easter eggs included for Cruella fans to spot, like the inclusion of Tallulah Bankhead's famous laugh which inspired Glenn Close's performance, in particular. But do I see this film as a Cruella de Vil original film? No. No, I don't. It's fun, though. I give it that.