Fantastic writing, wonderful story and storytelling, I loved how the mainline scenes were directed from a cinematography point of view, loveable characters that got me to care about them, a mature and sensible development of love interests, beautiful design, very fun battle mechanics, the music is amazing. The voice acting captured the essence of the characters and got me to care for them (especially Clive, Cid, Joshua, Gav, Mid, Jill, Benedicta, Dion. Annabella got me to hate her, so good job!)
The 4/5 stars is because some parts of the pacing really slowed down and took the wind out of the sails, some side missions were pointless/boring and their associated conversations were purely skippable without missing anything important. Also for a PS5 game there was a decent amount of poor framerates which made no sense.
Also loot was basically pointless. The lack of status effects was missed, but not horrible for me.
At the end of it all, it's a beautiful tale in a beautiful world with fantastic world building. I'd give it a 8.75/10 overall, but my enjoyment of the story/characters/battle was a 9.5/10.