This is one of those movies that is like walking into a restaurant and getting a bunch of raw ingredients on your plate, 'here, make something good out of that!' Well I'm sorry but there wasn't anywhere near enough of interest here to make me want to put the pieces of his past together and work out why he is what he is, I just didn't care. Long, drawn out scenes with little dialogue and shots lingering on pointless things for too long will do that to you. There's no debate Joaquin Phoenix is a good actor but that, and it being shot well don't make for a good movie if the rest of it resembles a barren desert. I don't have a problem with minimalist movies if they have something special about them; some atmosphere to get drawn into, this had very little of that, I found it very dull from beginning to end.