While it's not a perfect film, it's a great Phantom of the Opera film adaptation. A lot of people's feathers get ruffled because Gerard isn't a professional singer. While I can understand this gripe, his acting is wonderful and I personally find his singing still very good (especially considering that he isn't a professional singer). He brings a darkness to the Phantom's role that I feel like we don't normally see in the Broadway production. This is probably also the best Phantom of the Opera film that you'll find. There's many POTO films that exist, but most of them are truly awful. This one is beautiful, well acted, and has great music.